
Comanche Creek, Colorado, 1875: Prisoner Jack Mason is broken out of jail by a gang of strangers. They use him in a robbery, then when the dead-or-alive reward is high enough, they shoot him and collect. The National Detective Agency, now knowing the gang's methods, arranges to have agent Bob Gifford jailed in Comanche Creek for train robbery. The gang takes the bait (not before Gifford catches the eye of lovely saloon-keeper Abbie). But how will the bait get off the hook?

Audie Murphy
Bob 'Gif' Gifford aka Judd Tanner

DeForest Kelley
Amos Troop

Ben Cooper
Bill 'Kid' Carter

Colleen Miller
Abbie Stevens

Jan Merlin
Nielson

Adam Williams
Jed Hayden

Susan Seaforth Hayes
Janie

Mort Mills
Ben Bayer

John Milford
Bill Peters
Michael T. Mikler
Deputy

Thomas Browne Henry
Mike O'Brien

William Wellman Jr.
Deputy

Dead Man
Dead Man

Colorado Territory
Colorado Territory

The Return of Frank James
The Return of Frank James

The Great Scout & Cathouse Thursday
The Great Scout & Cathouse Thursday

The Culpepper Cattle Co.
The Culpepper Cattle Co.

Westbound
Westbound

The Old Way
The Old Way

Colorado Kid
Colorado Kid

Colorado
Colorado

Colorado Ranger
Colorado Ranger

Prairie Schooners
Prairie Schooners

The Outcast
The Outcast